Skip to content
Local News

Tolleson school district sued over $13,000 records fee

Goldwater Institute sued Tolleson Union High School District over a $13,000 public-records fee. The district says free in-person inspection was offered.

By Published

The Goldwater Institute is asking a Maricopa County Superior Court judge to overturn a $13,000 public-records charge imposed by Tolleson Union High School District, a dispute that could clarify how Arizona public bodies price access to records they maintain electronically.

The special-action complaint, dated Nov. 19 and released Nov. 20, alleges the district used a $1-per-page policy to block meaningful access to purchase orders, invoices and receipts. No court has ruled on the allegations.

The district disputes that characterization. Superintendent Jeremy Calles said the district offered free in-person inspection and said many expenses highlighted by Goldwater had student or conference-related purposes. In a statement reported by ABC15, Calles also said the governing board had not yet been formally served with the lawsuit.

How the $13,000 dispute developed

Goldwater requested all district purchase orders from the 2024-25 fiscal year on March 30, according to the complaint. It said electronic delivery was preferred and offered up to $100 for copies.

The complaint says the district estimated on Aug. 27 that at least 6,500 purchase orders were responsive and that copies would cost $13,000. Goldwater then asked whether the documents could be produced electronically to avoid or reduce copying charges. The district responded Sept. 11 that it was not obligated to provide electronic copies and asked whether Goldwater wanted to proceed at $1 per page, the complaint says.

A separate Aug. 20 request sought supporting documents for 37 expense-voucher entries approved by the governing board two days earlier. Those entries included $35,400 for advertising, $32,930 for employee coaching and leadership development, $15,670.84 to a limousine company and $6,320.97 to Arrowhead Country Club, according to the complaint.

For that narrower request, the district invoiced Goldwater $362.95 for 348 pages and estimated postage, plus $16.07 for another 15 pages and postage. Goldwater offered up to $200 for copies and again requested electronic production.

The suit does not ask the court to decide whether those underlying purchases were lawful. Its single legal claim concerns the price and format of access to the records.

District explains the listed expenses

Calles said the payment to the limousine company covered a motor coach used by students, not a luxury passenger vehicle. He said student clubs can raise money for charter buses and field trips, including trips to Knott’s Berry Farm and Andretti Indoor Karting and Games.

He also said an Arrowhead Country Club payment involved an off-site prom and that resort charges reflected staff attendance at conferences. The district offered Goldwater an opportunity to inspect the records and photograph them without paying a copying fee, according to the statement reported by ABC15.

Calles said the Arizona Auditor General had been reviewing the district for 15 months and had not produced findings that supported complaints from Goldwater or the Legislature’s Joint Legislative Audit Committee. That statement is the district’s account of the review, not a court finding in this case.

What Arizona law says

Arizona’s public-records law allows people to inspect records during regular office hours or request copies, and permits custodians to collect copying and postage charges in certain circumstances. Arizona legal guidance distinguishes copying costs from the cost of searching for records.

The complaint also cites the Arizona Supreme Court’s 2009 Lake v. City of Phoenix decision, which held that an electronic version of a public record, including embedded metadata, is subject to disclosure when a public body maintains the record electronically.

Goldwater alleges the district’s $1-per-page fee exceeds its actual reproduction cost, may include impermissible search or retrieval expenses and becomes an unlawful barrier when paired with the refusal to send electronic files. The district’s response is that inspection remained available for free and that $1 per page is an appropriate copying charge.

Goldwater is asking the court to order production in electronic form at a lawful fee, declare the $1-per-page charge unlawful, restrict future fees to actual reproduction costs and award attorneys’ fees. The next procedural steps are formal service, a district response and a court decision on whether to accept and grant the requested special-action relief.

More from West Valley Post

Discussion

Comments

Join the conversation. Keep comments relevant, civil and focused on the story.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.